A Historic Cheese Shop in New York's Little Italy Is Closing After 130 Years in Business Economic hardships are the closing doors of Alleva Dairy, the oldest cheese shop in America. Previous Article Subway Is Saying Sayonara to Its Pre-sliced Meats and Introducing Deli Slicers to All U.S. Restaurants Next Article Bill Gates Is Reportedly Dating Paula Hurd, Widow of Ex-Oracle CEO